Performance Cars $75K-$150K: Gold Star Value Awards 2015

Performance Cars $75K-$150K: Gold Star Value Awards 2015

Punch doesn't have to punch a hole in your bank balance.

Mercedes-AMG A45

Mini -Copper -CabrioMERC’S A45 AMG might be an expensive car in isolation, but in terms of the performance it offers for the money – both initial outlay and ongoing costs – it’s actually a ripper bargain. Hey, what else does 0-100km/h in 4.4sec and a 12-second quarter for $76K? Sure, it drinks 98-octane premium, but it can get 6.9L/100km (on the official test, at least).

The service interval is long (12 months), which means more time baiting BMW owners and less time in the workshop, while the 60 percent resale is pretty good – it sheds $30K in three years.

BMW M235i

BMW-M235iIT DOESN’T quite have the AMG’s grunt, and without AWD it can’t hope to match its acceleration figures, but BMW’s rear-drive alternative is more involving, and runs happily on 95 RON.

Lotus Elise S Roadster

Lotus -Elise -S-RoadsterSIMILAR speed to the pair that beat it, but that’s not the point in the Lotus, which is the nearest thing you can get to a road-legal go-kart. Strong resale makes buying new a reasonable proposition, and gives you a handy three years of warranty.

Performance Cars $75K-$150K Mercedes-AMG A45 4MATIC BMW M235i Lotus Elise S Roadster 1.8SC
Purchase Price $75,700 $79,930 $84,990
Combined cycle fuel (L/100km) 6.9 8.1 7.5
Fuel RON (min. rec.) 98 95 95
Three-year fuel cost $4431 $4923 $4558
Redbook resale (%) 60.3 57.8 58.6
Three-year depreciation $30,053 $33,730 $35,186
AAMI insurance premium $1766 $1529 $2003
Service interval (months) 12 12 12
Warranty (years) 3 3 3

Sign up here to receive the latest round-up of Wheels news, reviews and video highlights straight to your inbox each week.

Want free access to 5 years of Wheels archive content? Sign up now!