2017 Holden Astra sedan review

2017 Holden Astra sedan review

THE Astra range in Australia grows larger with the addition of the new Astra sedan to the local line-up. However, while the badge on the bootlid is the same as that worn by Holden’s European-sourced Astra hatch, there’s very little shared DNA between them.

WHAT IS IT?

Though it wears an Astra badge, the new Holden Astra sedan is in essence a re-badged Chevrolet Cruze that’s a generational leap over the one that used to be built here. It’s bigger inside and out than its hatchbacked counterpart, and there are significant differences in how it is priced, equipped and tuned compared with the existing Astra hatch.

WHY WE'RE TESTING IT

As a four-door companion to the Astra hatchback that launched here late last year, the new Astra sedan replaces the formerly locally made Cruze to help flesh out Holden’s small car range.

MAIN RIVALS

Mazda 3 sedan, Honda Civic sedan, Hyundai Elantra, Toyota Corolla sedan, Mitsubishi Lancer, Volkswagen Jetta

THE WHEELS VERDICT

The badge is deceiving here, for the Astra sedan is far from being an Astra hatch with a bigger rump. Softer, bigger and tuned for comfort above all else, the four-door Astra is Holden’s limousine-lite.


PLUS: Exceptionally refined, plush ride; affordable pricetags

MINUS: No AEB; interior not as polished as hatch, no 1.6 turbo

THE WHEELS REVIEW

HOLDEN has added a new body style to the Astra family, with the Astra sedan rolling into local showrooms this week to help improve the Red Lion’s fortunes in the ultra-competitive small car segment.

However, what you’re looking at is an Astra in name only. Sourced from Chevrolet rather than Opel, which provides the Astra hatch, the Astra sedan is, if you scrape beneath the surface, a rebadged Chevy Cruze. A Cruze that’s been tweaked and honed for our market, sure, but a Cruze nevertheless.


And with sheetmetal, interior plastics and critical dimensions that differ greatly from those of its five-door stablemate, the Astra sedan can’t be thought of as being simply an Astra hatch with a boot. It looks, feels and drives differently, but Holden isn’t bothered by that – the company says the sedan will appeal to a more mature demographic than the hatch.  

There is, however, some commonality between four- and five-door Astras. The 1.4-litre turbo four-pot that serves in the Astra R and R+ hatch powers the entire three-variant Astra sedan range, and though its 110kW and 240Nm outputs are modest in comparison to the Astra RS and RS-V’s firecracker 1.6 turbo, it’s smooth, tractable and more than merely adequate.

On the launch route through the Queensland hinterland, it easily lugged four adults up hills at just 2000rpm – the point at which peak torque rolls in – and always felt relaxed, unfussed and exceptionally quiet. It may be the tiddliest engine in the Astra family, but it’s a sweet powerplant regardless.

Paired with the slick-shifting six-speed automatic that’s optional in the base LS grade and standard in LT and LTZ, it’s especially good.


The other thing the Astra sedan shares with the hatch is its platform, however it’s been elongated for the sedan to accommodate a 38mm longer wheelbase, making it almost 280mm longer overall. Think the Honda Civic sedan is huge? The Astra sedan is even lengthier.

All that extra metal goes into improving rear-seat space and endowing a sizable boot capacity, and therein lies the Astra sedan’s greatest virtue – it excels at carrying people and their luggage. Fancy a bit of casual Uber driving in your spare time? This is the whip you want.

Front-seat accommodation is about on par with the hatch, but rear-seat legroom is positively limo-like in its generosity. The rear seat backrest is also tilted at a comfortable angle, giving two adults (it’s a bit squeezy for three) a relaxed and reclined posture. Folding the centre armrest down makes better use of that narrow centre seat, but it’s a shame there are no face-level vents for back-seaters.


Above the rear axle lies a capacious 445 litre boot, which easily swallows up enough luggage for a family getaway. The boot lip is high, though, and gooseneck hinges intrude into the boot area when the lid is shut.

But while the Astra hatch’s interior flaunts a clean and smart European design, the sedan, designed to appeal to US and Asian tastes, is chintzy and lacks the same elegance. On the plus side, at least you can easily tell which grade you’re in by whether the dash trim wears cloth or pleather – the hatch only gives you gloss-black plastic trim no matter how much you shell out, though the hatch’s satin-finish silver highlights are classier than the sedan’s plasti-chrome embellishments.

Cabin quality was also variable, with some cars having tighter dashboard panel gaps than others. More crucially for the safety-conscious, AEB isn’t offered at all in the Astra sedan range despite being standard on the hatch from R+ grade and up.

The Astra sedan’s locally honed suspension is another key point of difference between it and the hatch, with Holden deliberately tuning its dampers to move it closer to the comfort side of the ride/handling spectrum. On craggy Queensland tarmac it does a superb job of ironing out lumps in the road and practically floats over some truly nasty surfaces, but there are a couple of caveats.


For one, the 18-inch alloys of the top-shelf LTZ grade introduce plenty of sharpness to the ride, making it jitter over smaller corrugations and generally spoiling the comfort advantage of the sedan’s soft spring rates. The 16-inchers of the base LS are far more compliant, while the 17-inch alloys of the mid-spec LT aren’t too objectionable, either.

The other catch is that the sedan simply doesn’t have the dynamic crispness of the hatch. Though equipped with a torsion-beam rear axle like the Astra hatch, the sedan is missing the stability-enhancing rear Watts linkage flaunted by the hatchback. Soft spring rates may be great for dispatching pockmarked roads, but it’s clear that the sedan isn’t as confident in a corner as its five-door sibling.

The sedan’s electrically assisted steering also has a higher rack ratio than the hatchback, though it shares the same on-centre precision and progressive weighting. It requires a few more degrees of lock, but that’s in keeping with the car’s generally softer nature.


And that needs to be kept in mind when considering the Astra sedan. It may share a name, but it’s a different beast to the five-door in more ways than one. Little wonder that GM keeps the two cars quite separate in its overseas markets.

With a keen starting price of $20,490, value, space and comfort are the Astra sedan’s greatest virtues. Don’t expect the same European panache as the hatchback, and you won’t be disappointed.

SPECS

Model: Holden Astra LT sedan
Engine: 1399cc 4cyl, dohc, 16v, turbo
Max power: 110kW @ 6500rpm
Max torque: 240Nm @2000-4000rpm
Transmission: 6-speed automatic
Weight: 1294kg
Economy: 6.1L/100km (claimed)
Price: $25,790
On sale: Now

Sign up here to receive the latest round-up of Wheels news, reviews and video highlights straight to your inbox each week.